Top Property Managers in Cape Cod, Massachusetts

The short-term rental market in Cape Cod offers a unique blend of coastal charm, historic appeal, and strong seasonal demand. With thousands of vacationers visiting each year, STRs across Cape Cod—from Falmouth to Provincetown—remain a preferred option for families, couples, and groups. Driving forces behind Cape Cod’s robust rental market include:

• Iconic coastal scenery, with easy access to beaches, lighthouses, and bike paths.
• A strong tradition of family vacations, often with multi-generational guests booking large homes.
• Popular summer events, seafood festivals, and charming downtown shopping districts.
• A loyal base of repeat visitors, particularly in the high-demand summer and early fall seasons.

Whether you own a beachside cottage or a luxury home tucked into the dunes, partnering with a trusted Cape Cod vacation rental property management company is essential to standing out in this highly seasonal and competitive market. The best local managers provide expert pricing strategies, attentive housekeeping, and clear homeowner communication to help maximize rental income and protect your investment.

With Wheelhouse's Navigator Tool, we compiled a list of some of the most reputable property managers in Cape Cod, Massachusetts. These companies are chosen based on their strong reputations, positive customer reviews, comprehensive range of services, and their significant contributions to the local short-term rental market.

Locally Rooted, Performance-Focused

With 92 homes under management, Nauset Rental takes a hyper-local approach to Cape Cod property management, offering homeowners personalized service backed by strong data. Their revenue team monitors seasonal fluctuations, local events, and historical trends to keep rates competitive. Their housekeeping crews are carefully vetted and trained to maintain consistent, high standards. Owners receive ongoing communication, custom recommendations, and monthly performance updates designed to grow property value and guest satisfaction.

Luxury Vacation Rentals, Carefully Curated

Pretty Picky Properties manages 240 upscale homes across the Cape. Their revenue management system is informed by detailed analytics and focuses on rate optimization throughout the summer high season. Their cleaning protocols go above and beyond, with meticulous pre-arrival inspections and post-departure reviews. Homeowners benefit from a concierge-level management experience, with open communication, proactive advice, and regular reporting that ensures transparency and long-term results.

Tech-Enabled, Guest-Focused Property Management

With a portfolio of 400 properties, Del Mar Vacations is one of the largest and most innovative short-term rental managers on Cape Cod. Their proprietary pricing technology adjusts rates daily based on real-time market conditions and competitor benchmarks. Housekeeping is performed by in-house teams trained to deliver hotel-grade cleanliness and consistency. Homeowners enjoy real-time dashboards, detailed financial reporting, and strategic support that scales with their goals.e.

Historic Cape Cod Management with a Modern Touch

Chatham Rentals manages 250 properties in and around one of Cape Cod’s most iconic towns. Their experienced team blends traditional hospitality with modern pricing tools to maximize occupancy and rates. Housekeeping is a top priority, with personalized checklists, property reviews, and responsive service teams. Homeowners benefit from clear communication, honest feedback, and a collaborative approach that builds trust and results.

Experienced Management with a Personal Approach

With 240 homes under management, Martha Murray Vacation Rentals offers decades of Cape Cod property management expertise. Their team monitors market demand and adjusts pricing throughout the season for optimal returns. Their long-standing cleaning staff provides consistent, detail-oriented care. Homeowners appreciate the regular check-ins, clear monthly statements, and hands-on support that keep their properties running smoothly year after year.

Boutique Service with Proven Results

Pine Acres Realty manages 200 vacation properties and specializes in high-touch service across Cape Cod. Their revenue management is deeply tied to seasonal booking trends, ensuring properties are well-positioned during the competitive summer months. Housekeeping is meticulous, with quality checks and responsive teams on call. Owners receive individualized insights, direct access to management, and personalized strategies that reflect their goals.

Comprehensive Services for Cape Cod Homeowners

With 80 homes in their portfolio, Foran Realty delivers full-service vacation rental property management with a strong local presence. Their revenue team uses competitive pricing tools and local trend analysis to ensure maximum profitability. Their cleaning operations are known for dependability and high attention to detail. Homeowners are kept informed through routine updates, clear performance tracking, and a collaborative relationship built on trust and transparency.

Cape Cod’s vacation rental market is rich with opportunity for homeowners—especially when supported by a skilled, reliable, and communicative vacation rental property management company. From revenue optimization and deep-cleaning standards to personalized support, these top Cape Cod property managers make it easier to run a successful rental and create lasting guest experiences. With the right partner by your side, your Cape Cod home can shine in one of New England’s most beloved vacation destination.